Preserving the craft. Building its future.

Slate · Comparing fabrication bids

Who puts the holes in shaped ridge slates?

Identify which pieces arrive punched and who takes responsibility for the hole layout on shaped roof fittings.

By the Slate, Tile & Metal Guild ·

Two bids can name the same quarry, thickness and ridge quantity but include different amounts of fabrication. A supplier offering shaped ridge pieces may have priced the outline alone. A contractor expecting ready-punched pieces may have allowed only for setting them. Neither number tells you whether anyone has priced the hole layout.

The National Slate Association’s uniform-roof guide specification offers the specifier an option to receive hip, ridge and approach slates unpunched and have their holes made on site. It treats starter pieces separately. A guide with alternative clauses needs a project selection before it can resolve a disagreement over the order.

Use one marked piece to clarify the price

Ask the installer to identify one representative piece on the approved detail and mark which end and face the drawing shows. Have the supplier state which operations its quotation covers for that piece. If hole positions depend on field fit, identify who will mark them and who will prepare the material. If shop preparation is specified, record whose approved template controls and how revised dimensions reach the shop.

Apply the decision only to the pieces it covers. A field-slate specification for prepunched units can coexist with a site-prepared ridge. Put the two lines in the bid comparison and retain the sketch with the purchase order. The Guild’s slate estimate comparison gives a broader way to check scope differences before accepting a price.

Further reading

National Slate Association — Guide Specification for Uniform Slate Roofs, nail-hole provisions. See the cited source for the scope of its guidance.

Published by the Guild as part of Tim Kelly’s Slate Boss resource network. These educational guides support project conversations and do not replace an on-site inspection or a project specification.

← All roofing articles