Preserving the craft. Building its future.

Slate · Project planning

Compare slate repair estimates by scope, not the bottom-line price

Compare access, slate replacement, metalwork, concealed conditions and completion records before choosing a repair proposal.

By the Slate, Tile & Metal Guild ·

Two prices for ‘repairing the slate roof’ can describe very different jobs. One may cover a handful of broken slates; another may include opening a valley, replacing metalwork and reinstating the surrounding stone. Putting the totals side by side before comparing the work can create a false impression of value.

Start with the same observed problem

Give each prospective contractor the same inspection information and the same requested outcome. Identify the roof areas involved and distinguish a diagnosed defect from a reported symptom. ‘Water stain in the upstairs hall after rain’ is an observation. ‘The valley needs replacing’ is a proposed diagnosis that should have supporting evidence.

Ask each firm to explain how its scope addresses the problem. Preservation Brief 29 from the National Park Service discusses slate condition, flashing and fastening failures separately. That is a useful starting point for comparing a repair: replacing visible broken pieces and addressing a leaking junction are different tasks, even if both are needed on one roof.

Put the inclusions into a simple comparison

For each estimate, record the proposed work under the same headings:

  • Access and protection: how the work area will be reached and existing roofing and surroundings protected.
  • Slate: the locations, expected quantities, matching approach and replacement method to be agreed with the specialist.
  • Metalwork and drainage: which valleys, flashings, gutters or junctions are included.
  • Concealed conditions: what is assumed and how additional findings will be documented and priced.
  • Completion: cleanup, photographs, owner records and the written terms applying to the work.

Do not fill blank cells with assumptions. Ask whether an omitted item is excluded, unnecessary after inspection or simply awaiting a decision. If a contractor offers only a temporary measure, its purpose and limitations should be written clearly.

Resolve the unknowns before choosing

Consider this planning example: one proposal replaces twelve slates, while another removes and reinstates a defined area to repair flashing. These are not competing prices for identical work. First establish whether both contractors agree on the source of the problem. Then request comparable alternatives or a clear explanation of the different recommendations.

Ask who will carry out the slate work and request relevant project references. Confirm current licensing and insurance where applicable, and make sure the proposed materials and methods suit the actual roof. A directory entry is an introduction, not a verification of every qualification or a guarantee of workmanship.

Use Slate Roofing USA’s guides to prepare questions and the contractor directory to identify firms to investigate. The most useful quote is one whose scope, assumptions and expected outcome you can explain back in plain language.

Further reading

National Park Service — Preservation Brief 29: The Repair, Replacement, and Maintenance of Historic Slate Roofs. This historical preservation reference supports the material discussion; current product requirements and project-specific assessment govern actual work.

Published by the Guild as part of Tim Kelly’s Slate Boss resource network. These educational guides support project conversations and do not replace an on-site inspection or a project specification.

← All roofing articles