In an oral history collected for Harry S Truman National Historic Site, historian Ron Cockrell asked Ardis Ragland Haukenberry when a house had changed from slate to shingles. She was surprised to learn the slate was gone. Another participant, Tom Richter, suggested the late 1950s or early 1960s. All three remarks sit together on the page. Only one contains a date, and it comes from the person estimating when the work happened.
Imagine a building file reduced to one line: “Haukenberry recalled replacement around 1960.” That sentence would give a future restoration team both a witness and a date that the interview does not supply.
Make a note another researcher can check
Copy the interview identifier and the names of the speakers into the building file. Give the previous roof material, the fact of a change and the proposed date separate entries. For each, record who introduced it and the basis they gave. Here the interviewee’s surprise belongs in the file alongside the estimate. It explains why attributing the date to her would change the meaning.
Use the suggested years to narrow a search for dated photographs, invoices or a maintenance ledger. If those records turn up, cite them next to the event they establish. Until then, label the interval as a lead. That distinction matters when a restoration scope refers to the roof as it appeared in a particular year. The Slate Roofing USA archive guide lists other places to look for dated material.
