Preserving the craft. Building its future.

Slate · Renovation planning

Before anyone lifts a sample from a slate-look roof

An older addition can have a different covering from the main slate roof. Identify the uncertain area and plan professional assessment before disturbing it.

By the Slate, Tile & Metal Guild ·

A homeowner has an invoice for natural slate on the main house. From the driveway, the gray shingles on a later porch addition look much the same. A supplier asks for a broken corner to match. Before anyone removes a piece, check exactly which roof the invoice describes.

The National Park Service documents the historic use of asbestos shingles to imitate traditional roof slate in Preservation Brief 16. Appearance alone cannot establish whether an unfamiliar shingle contains asbestos. An invoice tied to the main slope is evidence about the main slope. Carrying its material description over to the porch can turn a routine sample request into the first disturbance of an unassessed material.

What to send the estimator today

Send a roof plan or simple sketch labeling the house and porch separately, a ground-level photograph of each, and the dated invoice. State which area is documented and which is awaiting identification. Describe whether the proposed job involves disturbing the porch covering. If the work is confined to another part of the roof, ask the contractor to mark the access route as well as the repair area so you can tell whether it would cross the porch.

Who decides whether a sample is needed?

EPA recommends testing suspect materials when damaged or when planned work would disturb them. It advises having a trained, accredited asbestos inspector take any samples and a qualified laboratory analyze them. Leave suspect material in place while arranging that assessment. Do not break off a corner or collect loose fragments for the supplier.

Ask for the sample location to be identified in the resulting report. The estimator can then revise the scope for the material and location actually assessed. Keep the supplier’s color-matching request separate until the appropriate professional has addressed disturbance. For documented natural slate elsewhere on the building, Slate Roofing USA’s sample-request guide covers the information a supplier needs for matching.

Further reading

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency — Identifying suspect materials, including shingles. EPA describes when testing is appropriate and who should collect samples for laboratory analysis.

Published by the Guild as part of Tim Kelly’s Slate Boss resource network. These educational guides support project conversations and do not replace an on-site inspection or a project specification.

← All roofing articles