Preserving the craft. Building its future.

Slate · Inspection

What a useful slate roof inspection report should tell you

A practical way to read a slate roof inspection: separate observations, likely causes, access limits and the next decision.

By the Slate, Tile & Metal Guild ·

A report that says only ‘old slate roof’ leaves a building owner with very little to act on. A useful inspection explains which parts of the roof were examined, what was found and how those findings support the recommended work. That distinction matters when an isolated defect and a wider roof problem can look similar from the ground.

Ask for a map, not just a collection of photographs

The report should identify each roof slope and locate its photographs. A simple plan with numbered views is often easier to use than dozens of unlabeled close-ups. Ask the inspector to distinguish broken pieces, missing pieces, slipping slate and visible surface deterioration. Note which observations came from the ground, a lift, the attic or close access. Areas that could not be inspected belong in the report too.

This is also where the owner can contribute useful information. Record when a stain first appeared, whether it changes after rain and which rooms are affected. Those observations are clues to investigate; they do not establish the entry point by themselves.

Separate the stone from the rest of the assembly

The National Park Service’s Preservation Brief 29 explains that a repair decision needs to consider the condition of the slate alongside flashings, fasteners and other potential sources of moisture. A leaking junction does not, by itself, establish that every slate is exhausted. Equally, attractive stone seen from the street does not establish that the hidden fastening or supporting system is sound.

Ask for separate findings on the slate, accessible metalwork, drainage and accessible supporting construction. Where concealed conditions remain unknown, the report should say what additional investigation would resolve them. A confident conclusion without an adequate inspection is less useful than an honest statement of what remains uncertain.

Turn the findings into a decision

A helpful recommendation sets out immediate work, planned repairs and items to monitor. For each item, ask for its location, the reason for action and the consequence of deferring it. If replacement is recommended, request the evidence that makes repair impractical on this particular roof or slope. Avoid treating a building’s age or a single percentage as an automatic replacement rule.

  • Which defects need prompt attention?
  • Which components are still serviceable?
  • What further access or investigation is required?
  • What will be documented after the work?

Keep the report with dated photographs and subsequent invoices. The next specialist should be able to follow the roof’s history. Use the Slate Roofing USA contractor directory as a starting point, then confirm the firm’s actual slate inspection and repair experience directly. Owners should gather records and safely accessible views; roof access belongs with properly equipped professionals.

Further reading

National Park Service — Preservation Brief 29: The Repair, Replacement, and Maintenance of Historic Slate Roofs. This historical preservation reference supports the material discussion; current product requirements and project-specific assessment govern actual work.

Published by the Guild as part of Tim Kelly’s Slate Boss resource network. These educational guides support project conversations and do not replace an on-site inspection or a project specification.

← All roofing articles