Preserving the craft. Building its future.

Slate · Building history

Can a fire insurance map date a slate reroof?

Use a Sanborn map’s publication and revision history to test a roof chronology before putting an installation year in a preservation report.

By the Slate, Tile & Metal Guild ·

A board preparing a grant application has an old fire insurance map and a simple question: is the slate as old as the building? Start with the copy in front of you. Two copies bearing the same publication year may record different versions of the block. The Library of Congress describes field copies of Sanborn maps that remained in use for decades and acquired printed corrections pasted onto the sheets.

Read the edition and the individual sheet together

For a hypothetical example, suppose an atlas was printed in 1910 and its catalog entry reports corrections through 1935. A roof notation over the property is visible in the scan. The 1910 date alone does not establish that the notation was present that year. The 1935 date alone does not establish when the roof was replaced either. Look for an uncorrected copy of the same sheet, compare the footprint and notation, and consult the legend issued with that edition. Record the exact category the legend allows. If it groups coverings, leave the narrower material identification open.

Give the owner a defensible sentence

File the town, volume, sheet, edition, correction range and link beside the observation. One honest entry might read “The corrected sheet shows a rear wing; the copy examined does not date its roofing work.” That still helps the team: a photograph predating the wing can now be set aside when researching its slate.

To assign an installation year, look for evidence that ties the work to that part of the building. A dated invoice describing the rear wing or a sequence of dated construction photographs may narrow the interval. Keep the map observation and the installation evidence as separate entries so a later researcher can update either one. Slate Roofing USA’s archive search guide gives a starting point for that next search.

Further reading

Library of Congress — Sanborn Maps collection data and field revisions. The Library explains how field copies accumulated printed corrections over time.

Published by the Guild as part of Tim Kelly’s Slate Boss resource network. These educational guides support project conversations and do not replace an on-site inspection or a project specification.

← All roofing articles