Preserving the craft. Building its future.

Slate · Comparing reclaimed lots

What does a reclaimed slate actually cost after sorting?

Compare delivered offers using the number of usable, matching slates and see how an uncertain sorting yield changes the result.

By the Slate, Tile & Metal Guild ·

A salvage seller offers a lot by the piece. The repair contractor needs pieces of a particular size and condition. Until someone reconciles those two counts, the lower sticker price can be the more expensive offer. The National Slate Association advises sellers to sort reclaimed slates by size and condition.

Put both offers on the same basis

Consider two illustrative quotes, with delivery included. Lot A costs $600 for 300 pieces as received. If sorting leaves 200 suitable for the repair, the effective material price is $3 per usable piece before sorting labor. Lot B costs $550 for 220 pieces already sorted to the required size and accepted condition. At the confirmed count it works out to $2.50 each. These hypothetical prices illustrate a calculation and say nothing about local market value.

Where is the break-even point? At $2.50 per usable piece, Lot A must yield 240 pieces to justify its $600 price. If the crew will spend another $50 sorting A, the threshold rises to 260. And if the project needs 250 pieces, even a bargain lot of 220 leaves a real sourcing gap.

Record the verified matching count, the number still awaiting inspection and the contractor’s acceptance criteria before committing to the lot. Treat an assumed yield as an estimate until a qualified reviewer sees the material. The Slate Roofing USA order guide helps define the size and selection to which that count applies.

Further reading

National Slate Association — Get Money for Salvaged Slate. The reference supports the material or estimating discussion.

Published by the Guild as part of Tim Kelly’s Slate Boss resource network. These educational guides support project conversations and do not replace an on-site inspection or a project specification.

← All roofing articles