Preserving the craft. Building its future.

Slate · Specification review

Does “S1” on an imported slate report answer the architect’s S1 requirement?

Read the test heading and standard before entering a grade in a bid comparison.

By the Slate, Tile & Metal Guild ·

Put two headings above the letters S1. One says “ASTM C406 grade” on a US project schedule. The other says “sulphur dioxide exposure” on a European slate report. Copying the letters from the second column into the first would turn a result for one test into a claim about a different specification.

UK Slate’s Kentdale Ultra report illustrates the distinction. The first page identifies the product, sampling date and edition of the European standard. It lists separate results for several properties, including water absorption and thermal cycling. S1 appears against sulphur dioxide exposure. Keep those words attached when quoting the result. The report records a particular product sample tested in 2016.

Leave the unanswered cell open

Suppose the bid requires an ASTM Grade S1 slate and this European report is the only enclosure. Enter its title, product and result in the evidence column. Mark the ASTM grade as awaiting documentation. That avoids both accepting an unsupported equivalence and rejecting a slate whose supplier may already have the requested paperwork.

Send the supplier the exact requirement and ask for the product-specific evidence under the specified edition. If an alternative test basis is proposed, identify who on the project can accept it and retain the written decision with the submittal. The Guild’s example of reading units on a slate test report addresses another way a correct lab entry can end up under the wrong heading.

Further reading

UK Slate — Kentdale Ultra test record under EN 12326-1:2004. See the cited source for the scope of its guidance.

Published by the Guild as part of Tim Kelly’s Slate Boss resource network. These educational guides support project conversations and do not replace an on-site inspection or a project specification.

← All roofing articles