An architect sees an uneven bottom edge on a sample panel and asks for a straighter course. Before the installer moves a tile, lay a few unused pieces from the shipment on a table and line up their tops. Look at the opposite ends. Does the variation in the panel already exist in the loose pieces?
Ludowici makes a distinction on page 42 of its shingle manual. Its rustic shingle tiles vary in length by design. With their heads on the layout line, the exposed lower edges can vary by about half an inch. Its formal shingles are more uniform in length and ordinarily run in straight courses. The manual also illustrates a separately staggered layout. Those are different ways to obtain the line that a viewer sees from the ground.
Keep a photograph of the concealed edge
Ask the installer to show the upper edges against the course line on the mockup before the next row goes on. Photograph that view alongside a finished view taken at the agreed viewing distance. Label the pair with the shingle profile and layout. A finished photograph alone can show the intended silhouette but cannot explain how the installer produced it.
If the owner prefers a straighter edge, have the designer settle the choice of profile and pattern with the installer before approving the panel. Moving individual pieces just to tidy the bottom line can change the overlap above them. Keep the decision and both photographs with the clay tile submittal so later repairs have a reference for both the appearance and the layout.
