A historic roof has a visible stripe in some slates. A replacement sample shows a similar stripe, and the accompanying letter cites ASTM C406/C406M-22. Before the architect records a grade against that sample, there is a material identification question to settle.
Section 1.2 of the specification excludes slate containing soft carbonaceous ribbons. Both the nature of the material in the band and its softness matter to that description. A photograph establishes the position and appearance of the band. Its color alone cannot establish composition, softness or whether the exclusion applies.
Connect the test evidence to the offered selection
Ask the supplier whether the selection offered for delivery includes the banded pieces, how the band was identified and whether the tested specimens represented that selection. Record the report’s sample designation next to the supplier’s product designation. If the report covers a selection from which ribboned pieces were removed, there is still an unanswered question about a pallet that includes them.
On a restoration, the owner may also want to retain a historic visual pattern. Record that goal separately so a color match cannot settle the material classification by accident. If the material falls outside the cited scope, have the specifier address the proposed basis for evaluation before approval. The Slate Roofing USA submittal guide can help trace the supporting sample and paperwork to the order.
