One roofing declaration reports an impact per kilogram of product. Another reports it per square metre. Comparing those printed numbers directly is meaningless. Converting them to the same unit is a necessary arithmetic step, but it does not establish that the studies describe equivalent products, service or life-cycle stages.
This worked exercise is relevant to natural slate, clay tile and concrete tile. All quantities and impact values below are fictional teaching inputs, not typical product weights, manufacturer results or a ranking of roofing materials.
Show the conversion, including its units
Suppose Document A states a global-warming-potential result of 0.30 kilograms of carbon-dioxide equivalent per kilogram of product for its stated production scope. Suppose the project calculation requires 40 kilograms of that product per square metre of installed field covering.
The conversion is 0.30 kg CO₂e/kg × 40 kg/m² = 12 kg CO₂e/m². The product-mass units cancel. “CO₂e” expresses carbon-dioxide equivalent; it is not a weight of roofing material.
A roofing square is 100 square feet, or approximately 9.2903 square metres. For the same narrow scope, 12 × 9.2903 = approximately 111.5 kg CO₂e per roofing square. Keep the unrounded intermediate value in the calculation and round only the reported result.
Check what the coverage input represents
The 40 kg/m² input must refer to product needed to cover installed roof area under the intended layout. Do not substitute the geometric face area of loose pieces if the installation overlaps them. Record the source of the coverage quantity, units and included components.
In this exercise, the input excludes waste, accessories and other roof layers. The result therefore does too. If a separate fictional procurement scenario adds 5 percent to this field-product quantity, the corresponding production-scope figure becomes 12 × 1.05 = 12.6 kg CO₂e/m². That is neither a recommended waste allowance nor a complete calculation of installation or disposal impacts. Do not add a waste factor again if the underlying model already includes it.
Stop before declaring a winner
Now suppose Document B displays 10 kg CO₂e/m². It appears lower, but the comparison remains unfinished. Check the declared products, product category rules, assessment methods, life-cycle stages, geography, dates and relevant assumptions. Establish equivalent performance and the assessment period; account for maintenance and replacements consistently where the study requires them.
GSA’s life-cycle glossary explains that function, quantity, performance and time belong in the functional unit. Its EPD guidance also explains that possessing a declaration does not establish environmental superiority.
Keep a conversion record with the original document, page or table, quantity source, formula and exclusions. Ask the project’s life-cycle specialist to resolve mismatches before making a comparative claim. For material-specific preparation, consult Slate Roofing USA and Tile Roofing USA’s introduction to environmental declarations. Equal units make the arithmetic readable; compatible study assumptions make the comparison meaningful.
