Preserving the craft. Building its future.

Slate · Reclaimed material

Why do these reclaimed slates have their top corners cut off?

A cropped shoulder can be evidence of earlier fitting. Sort it separately from a fresh corner break during a salvage review.

By the Slate, Tile & Metal Guild ·

A stack of salvaged slate arrives with its bottom edges intact. On many pieces one or both upper corners have been clipped. If the receiving tally has only a box for “corners broken,” useful historical information can disappear as quickly as the stock goes into the reject pile.

UK Slate describes a fitting practice called shouldering. A slater sometimes cropped the upper corners where the stone rested on a batten to help it sit flat. Consequently, a reclaimed piece can have deliberate cuts at the head even when its exposed tail is rectangular. A single missing corner by itself tells little about how it was lost.

Keep the original orientation

Set out a few loose pieces with the tails in the same direction. Photograph both faces, the old nail holes and the cropped edges. Repeated cuts at comparable positions support a different explanation from a fresh fracture running from a corner into a nail hole. Record both observations if they occur on the same piece.

Ask the project slater to review a representative group against the intended support, fastening position and required cover. Leave room in the tally for pieces suitable as field slates, pieces potentially usable for smaller cuts and pieces to reject. Counting a shoulder separately preserves the option to reuse the stone while keeping final selection with the installer. For other clues on removed pieces, see the guide to examining a slate’s underside.

Further reading

UK Slate · Basic Slating Guide, “Laying Slates”. The supplier describes shouldering in traditional battened slate work. Suitability for reuse depends on the individual slate and intended detail.

Published by the Guild as part of Tim Kelly’s Slate Boss resource network. These educational guides support project conversations and do not replace an on-site inspection or a project specification.

← All roofing articles