A close-up of a lump on a loose slate leaves out two details the reviewer needs. Which face is up, and where will the next course cover it? The same feature can sit clear of the overlying stone in one position and hold it up in another.
The Slate Roofing Contractors Association discusses raised features sometimes called knots or knuckles in section 2.2.F of its guidelines. It distinguishes a protrusion on the exposed upper face from one on the back or beneath an overlapping slate. Its acceptance criterion includes whether the piece can be laid properly. That makes a top-down photograph of surface texture a poor basis for deciding the fate of a whole shipment.
Show the contact point on a loose sample
Give the slater a representative loose piece and the course exposure from the project drawing. On a bench, a removable paper strip can identify the proposed exposure line without marking the stone. Take a face view with the head and tail identified, then a side view with the neighboring layer held in its intended position. If the stone rocks, indicate which two surfaces make contact.
Record the pallet and how many pieces were examined. Keep pieces needing review separate until the installer and supplier agree on their disposition under the project specification. A photograph documenting one interference gives them a location to check on other pieces. It cannot establish how frequently the feature occurs. File the labeled views with the slate material submittal so the next reviewer can reconstruct the proposed orientation.
