A sample board can show whether a replacement shingle resembles a piece of slate at arm’s length. It cannot show how much of an apartment courtyard is defined by the rooflines around it. That difference mattered in two rehabilitation cases documented by the National Park Service.
At a Colonial Revival apartment complex, repeated hipped and gabled slate roofs gave the otherwise simple buildings much of their character. After a survey found deterioration, the owner proposed a polymer substitute. The review found that approach incompatible and the owner agreed to use slate from the original quarry. At a Second Empire building on a narrow street, a deteriorated slate mansard played a smaller role among balconies, dormers, cornices and a central tower. The accepted polymer replacement reproduced the fish-scale pattern. Street views of the mansard were generally oblique.
Give the reviewer two kinds of evidence
Document the condition of the actual slate and the feasibility of retaining it first. Then photograph the building as a visitor approaches. For a group of buildings, include views across the shared grounds. Mark which slopes recur in those views and what the eye can distinguish, such as a patterned band or the shadows from thick tails. Pair those photographs with close views and physical samples of the existing and proposed materials.
Those records let the preservation team explain why an in-kind repair, an in-kind replacement or a proposed substitute would affect this particular place. A previous approval at another address gives the team questions to investigate. Obtain the applicable review for the current project and keep the comparison photographs with the decision.
