A foreman shows the architect a finished repair to a clay tile roof. The architect is satisfied with how the replacement sits among the old tiles. Two other people are due to carry out most of the work. What has that first repair established about the next two?
The U.S. General Services Administration’s procedure for historic clay tile repair gives the architect two things to judge. One is a mockup of the work, including how adjacent material will be protected. The other is the work of each mechanic. GSA calls for each person who will perform the repair to remove and replace a tile at a location selected by the architect, with the architect present. A product sample on a table answers the colour question. It leaves the crew’s ability to work among fragile neighbours untested.
Schedule enough time for the people doing the work
Suppose a contractor assigns three mechanics to a repair using the GSA procedure. Put all three on the demonstration schedule. Identify who will remove and replace which tile, where the architect will observe and who will record the result. A single demonstration by the foreman leaves two people to be assessed. If a different mechanic joins later, check that person’s demonstration status before assigning repairs.
Give the accepted sample an address on the roof plan, such as the course and bay counted from a labelled opening. Photograph both the repair and the surrounding tiles. GSA retains an accepted mockup as a benchmark. If a later repair sits higher or the neighbouring tiles show damage, the architect and contractor can return to the agreed example together. Keep the acceptance record beside the replacement tile matching record so the project file identifies both the material and the workmanship the team accepted.
