A supplier returns a sample with a scratch across one face and a note that the stone was checked by hand. A reviewer sees the words “hand scraping” on a weather-resistance test description. Can the note fill a missing entry in the slate submittal?
ASTM C217/C217M-22 gives hand scraping a particular meaning. It is one of two procedures for measuring how deeply slate softens after specified acid conditioning. The other uses a shear/scratch instrument. Running a tool over an untreated piece leaves a mark, but that mark supplies neither the conditioned specimen nor a measured softening depth. Even a clear photograph with a scale beside the mark cannot reconstruct those missing observations.
Keep the field observation and the lab request separate
Retain the sample identifier and photo with the material observations. If the specification calls for a laboratory result, request the report that connects the tested sample to the offered slate. Look for the standard and edition, procedure used, reported depth and units. If the supplier’s table gives a bare number, return it for identification before transferring the figure to the comparison sheet. A missing result can be left open without predicting how the stone would perform under test.
ASTM describes this result as one part of comparing slates. For the other entries commonly supplied with it, consult the guide to reading slate test reports.
