A slate removed during a repair has a neat round hole with a wider recess on the face. The condition survey calls it a modern replacement because the neighboring slates appear punched. Before that conclusion becomes a roof-wide count of replacements, look at figure 3 in the National Slate Association’s nail-hole bulletin. It shows a slate described as a century old from the Monson district of Maine, with drilled and counterbored holes.
Describe the hole before assigning a date
The narrow passage through the slate and the recess that accommodates the nail head are two different features. A punch driven from the back can leave a chipped recess on the face. Historic producers could also cut a recess around a drilled hole. Record the shape of each on a loose piece already removed by the roofer, with a scale and an identifier for its former location. The association records counterboring in more than one quarry district, so that detail alone cannot establish a Maine origin either.
Look next at where the change occurs. A group that follows the outline of a known addition poses a different question from one isolated piece beside a repaired valley. Ask for the dated work order or a photograph showing the area before that repair. Even a dated invoice for new slate establishes a purchase more readily than it establishes which particular pieces were installed.
A defensible survey entry might read “drilled and recessed holes on removed piece V-2, installation date unresolved.” Keep the observation when the date cannot yet be established. Slate Roofing USA’s guide to dating a roof identifies other records to compare.
