Preserving the craft. Building its future.

Concrete tile · Repair scope

If replacement tiles come from the rear slope, what goes back there?

Compare both areas of work when a proposal moves matching concrete tiles from one part of a roof to another.

By the Slate, Tile & Metal Guild ·

A roofer has located matching concrete tiles for a street-facing slope. They are already on the house, over a rear addition. The proposal says “reuse original tile at front.” Until it also describes the rear roof on completion, the owner cannot compare that price with an estimate based on purchased salvage.

The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance lists harvesting tiles from a less visible area as one option when an old line has been discontinued. The advantage is a supply of existing pieces that can be checked against the damaged field. Moving the tiles also creates another area of work. A new tile that looks similar from the yard can have a different side interlock or fastening geometry. Moving the mismatch to the rear leaves the fit question unresolved.

Put a boundary around both jobs

Suppose the front needs ten sound replacements. The contractor proposes renewing an entire small rear slope to obtain them. Ask for two marked outlines. At the front, identify the positions to be repaired and how candidates will be checked for condition and fit. At the rear, identify the new covering, where it terminates and how it meets adjoining old work at the ridge, walls or valleys. The estimate should include the rear work even if it occupies far more area than the ten front repairs.

Ask what happens if fewer than ten suitable tiles come off intact, who decides before the opening is enlarged, and which remaining sound tiles will be returned as spares. Record the final profile used on each slope for the next repair. A project-specific proposal should also identify any approvals needed for that scope. For background on evaluating pieces offered from another source, see the salvaged roof tile selection guide.

Further reading

Tile Roofing Industry Alliance · Discontinued Roofing Tiles in North America, Technical Bulletin 2026-04, repair or replace decision flowchart. The North American bulletin describes harvesting as a possible repair strategy. This example is hypothetical. Compatibility and the repair boundary require project-specific review.

Published by the Guild as part of Tim Kelly’s Slate Boss resource network. These educational guides support project conversations and do not replace an on-site inspection or a project specification.

← All roofing articles