A quarry name is a useful starting point for matching the stone. It can leave a contractor guessing about the labor. Historic England’s record for The Old House and studio in St. Merryn, Cornwall, describes Delabole slate on the roofs, then identifies two treatments: scantle work and rag slate. A supplier could recognize the material immediately while two estimators read quite different jobs into the same line.
The listing describes the scantles at this property as pegged with oak, laid in courses that diminish in size and bedded in wet lime mortar. The entry also identifies the use of rag slate. It gives a conservation team reasons to examine the roof plane by plane. It does not identify the construction of an unexamined slope elsewhere.
Turn the material entry into a repair scope
For each roof plane, mark the limits of the proposed repair. Beside the source of stone, give the course arrangement, the observed attachment and the location of any bedding. Identify which details were visible during survey and which need confirmation at an approved opening. Keep an unverified fastening method out of the “existing construction” column until there is evidence for it.
Where access is limited, ask each bidder to state the laying method assumed and what finding would change the price. At the first opening, have the team photograph the sequence before pieces are separated and agree any revised scope. A slate specialist can then distinguish finding comparable stone from reproducing the local method of laying it.
