Preserving the craft. Building its future.

Concrete tile · Comparing proposals

Do both concrete tile bids include the same gable finish?

A pointed mortar edge and a course of overlapping rake tiles call for different material and labor allowances.

By the Slate, Tile & Metal Guild ·

Two bids for the same tile roof can each promise a “finished gable” while buying different things. The gable edge, also called the rake, is the sloping edge seen from the end of the building. A photograph taken square to that end often shows the intended finish more clearly than the roof plan.

The Florida high-wind tile manual describes a rake-tile option and a mortar-finish option. The rake-tile detail uses separate trim pieces laid successively up the slope. The mortar option forms a smooth, straight edge. An estimator counting individual trim units and an estimator pricing a length of pointed mortar could each believe they have covered the architect’s note.

Get a price for the detail the owner expects

Mark each gable on the elevations. Beside each mark, record the edge treatment, its length and the drawing that shows its profile. For a rake-tile detail, ask the bidder to identify the trim profile, quantity, fastening allowance and treatment of the first piece at the eave. For a mortar finish, ask what preparation, finishing work and appearance sample the price includes.

Have the designer confirm the locally acceptable assembly and have both bidders price that choice. Carry any alternative on a separate line. This puts each gable finish in the tile accessory schedule and lets the owner compare the same finished edge on both proposals.

Further reading

FRSA and Tile Roofing Industry Alliance · Florida High Wind Concrete and Clay Tile Installation Manual, 7th edition, Rake/Gable. The Florida manual describes both edge treatments. The selected project detail and applicable approvals govern the work.

Published by the Guild as part of Tim Kelly’s Slate Boss resource network. These educational guides support project conversations and do not replace an on-site inspection or a project specification.

← All roofing articles