The structural drawing says 150 mph. The tile contractor’s worksheet says 116 mph. If both numbers appear under a heading that says only “wind speed,” the owner has good reason to ask how the contractor selected the lower figure. Start by asking for the original headings on both documents.
The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance manual uses two labels in its conversion table. Vult denotes the ultimate design wind speed. Vasd denotes the nominal design wind speed used for allowable stress design. The manual pairs 150 mph ultimate with 116 mph nominal. That pairing can explain the difference on a worksheet. If both documents actually say Vult, the same explanation fails.
Keep the labels attached to the numbers
For the drawing, record the sheet and revision along with “150 mph Vult.” For the worksheet, record the table number, edition and the label over the selected column. Ask the designer to confirm the speed basis that table expects. If the worksheet already received a converted value, applying the conversion a second time would give the wrong input.
The correspondence between two numbers resolves only that one question. The Alliance’s worked examples also identify the exposure, roof height, slope, tile and mounting arrangement. Keep those details with the attachment schedule. A claim that a tile is “rated for 150 mph” leaves an owner guessing which building and assembly the claim describes. The Tile Roofing USA wind and weather guide gives background for discussing the rest of the roof with the contractor.
