A house near an airport is getting a concrete tile reroof. The proposal cites an acoustic rating of 52, but the scope stops at the roof deck. Before using that figure to choose a bid, ask the bidder to identify the ceiling on the test drawing. The ceiling that will stay in the house may be the most important difference on that page.
Two drawings published by the Roofing Tile Association of Australia illustrate the problem. Both show concrete roof tile, foil below the battens and insulation above the ceiling. Drawing 2 has 13 mm plasterboard attached to the ceiling framing and lists a weighted sound reduction index (Rw) of 43. Drawing 4 has denser 13 mm board attached to steel furring channels and lists Rw 52. The board thickness alone would make the ceiling descriptions look identical on a short bid form.
Mark up a section through the room
Label what stays and what changes, from the roof tile down to the finished ceiling. If the existing ceiling attachment is unknown, record it as unknown. On the test drawing, circle the rating heading as well as the figure. The same examples also give a separate spectrum-adjusted value, Rw + Ctr. Copying a number without its heading loses that distinction.
Ask the project acoustician which rating addresses the aircraft noise at this site and what evidence represents the assembly over the room. Keep that answer with the reroof bid comparison. The published assembly figures alone cannot predict how much quieter the bedroom will sound after a covering-only job.
