Two red concrete tile samples look close when set face up. Turn a broken sample on edge and the colors may tell a different story. That matters at a detail where the finished work will expose a cut. The buyer needs to see the face the roofer will leave visible.
Westlake Royal describes two factory coloring methods. Pigment can be mixed into the concrete before the tile is formed. A manufacturer can also spread a pigmented cement mixture over the face of the newly formed tile. In the latter case the surface color alone says little about the color of the concrete beneath it. The bulletin also describes additives that can vary the appearance. A glossy finish by itself is a poor basis for identifying a particular product.
Ask for a sample that shows the finished detail
Use a loose offcut or an already broken spare to compare the face, the exposed body and an intact factory edge. Ask the supplier to identify the coloring process for the specific replacement product. Have the roofer mark which of those surfaces, if any, the intended detail will expose when viewed from the street. A difference visible on the workbench may be concealed on the roof.
If a cut will remain in sight, review it in a small sample of the proposed assembly before approving the order. Record the accepted face and edge together. Keep the maker’s finish description alongside the replacement tile identification record. It gives a future buyer more to work with than a color name on an invoice.
