When a proposal cites a percentage for a cooler tile roof, look for where the researchers put the sensor. An Oak Ridge National Laboratory study reported a 70% reduction in peak heat flow through the roof deck in a comparison with a direct-nailed asphalt shingle roof. The experiment considered tile surfaces and ventilation beneath the tile. The quantity measured was heat crossing one part of the building at peak conditions.
Suppose a homeowner pays $200 in electricity charges in July. Multiplying the bill by 70% produces $140, but the study provides no basis for entering $140 as monthly savings. The bill covers the meter for a month, while the reported percentage compares peak deck heat flow between test assemblies. Neither the household’s cooling electricity nor its price per kilowatt-hour appears in that percentage.
Ask for the assumptions behind a dollar estimate
Have the bidder identify the comparison roof. Replacing a dark shingle roof and replacing a light-colored tile roof begin from different baselines. Record the proposed tile finish, attachment, space beneath the covering, attic insulation and local climate. A tile surface rating helps describe the selected finish. The energy estimate still needs the rest of the assembly.
For the budget, ask for estimated annual cooling electricity in kilowatt-hours for each option, the electricity price used and any change in heating use. If the proposal contains only the deck measurement, retain it as evidence about the tested roof and leave the annual dollar field open.
