A specification calls for Grade 1 clay roof tile. The proposed replacement comes with a close color match and a sheet marked “ASTM C1167, Type III.” A reviewer copying the Roman numeral into the grade box could reject the tile as Grade 3. A reviewer who checks off the standard number alone could approve a product with its grade still unknown.
Give the two classifications their own lines
Miami-Dade County’s product notice for Ludowici Century Shake shows how the two labels can appear together. Its table identifies a flat interlocking clay tile, Type III, Grade 1. Reading III as a weathering grade would give the wrong answer for that very product. Copy the offered type into the profile or appearance line. On the weathering line, enter the specified grade in one column and the manufacturer’s documented grade for the offered product in another. Leave the offered grade open until the supplier identifies it.
For the example above, give the supplier the proposed model, the specification section and one short question: “What C1167 weathering grade does this model meet, and which document records it?” Attach the response to the substitution request so the designer can close the outstanding comparison. Keep the color approval alongside it. When comparing offers from multiple roofers, carry the open item into the tile reroof bid comparison.
