A row of replacement tiles can cast a different shadow from its neighbors even when the color, width and length look right. On a plain clay tile, the body can bow along its length, across its width, or in both directions. A supplier who sees only the broad face may miss which curve gives the old roof its appearance.
Marley’s Acme range illustrates the difference. Its single-camber plain tile curves along its length. Its double-camber tile also curves across the width. Looking across a display table at the long side reveals the first curve. Turn the same sample a quarter turn and look toward its exposed foot to see the second. Two long-side photographs, even from opposite sides, leave the same question unanswered.
Make a pair of comparable views
Use a loose spare or ask the roofer to photograph a piece already removed during planned work. Put a straight reference edge beside it, visible in the same plane as the edge being photographed. Mark the head and foot on a card beside the tile. Keep the camera level with each edge so perspective adds as little apparent bow as possible. Repeat the views with the supplier’s candidate in the same orientation.
Send the two pairs along with the tile matching record. If shadows still differ on the sample panel, the designer now has a specific feature to compare. The roofer should check the candidate among neighboring units before a repair order is released.
