Two bidders offer the same natural slate for a building with a wood roof deck. One names an ASTM D226 Type II underlayment. The other proposes a synthetic sheet and carries over the first bidder’s Class A claim. What document would justify that change?
New York City’s 2022 Building Code gives a concrete example. Section 1505.2 includes slate on noncombustible decks among its Class A exceptions. It separately identifies slate over a combustible deck when ASTM D226 Type II underlayment lies between them. A wood deck brings that underlayment line into the review. A product description that says only “synthetic” leaves its qualification unanswered.
For a project using that provision, ask the second bidder for the proposed product’s data and the basis for the exact assembly’s classification. A listing that covers the proposed layers may provide another route. Have the designer check the applicable code before accepting the substitution. The bid comparison can then identify exactly which assembly each price buys. See Slate Roofing USA’s guide to performance claims.
