Put “replace missing slates and repair nail holes in wood decking” into a bid form and the estimator has already made two decisions about the roof. At Biltmore House in Asheville, the original builders tied the roofing slates with copper wire to iron cross beams. The estate describes a deliberate effort to keep wood out of the roof for fire safety. Its construction history includes a period photograph of the iron framing.
Write down what connects to what
A photograph of the finished slope can show the shape of the slates. It offers little help with the end of a wire concealed behind them. In a bid survey, give the team room to record three separate observations: the roof covering, the fastener that engages it and the supporting member that receives the fastener. Alongside each, identify the evidence available for that particular roof area. An original drawing and an accessible view taken after a later repair can legitimately yield different answers.
If the team has only a view from the ground, leave the support and attachment open in the schedule. Ask who will resolve them before a unit price is applied across multiple slopes. A price built around renailing to boards tells an owner very little about the labor to reach and repair a concealed wire connection.
For buildings without an estate archive, the Slate Roofing USA guide to historic roof records suggests places to begin the search. The Biltmore detail is a historical reference, and any repair design belongs to the team assessing the actual assembly.
