When cataloguing an old roofing stone, it is tempting to trace the deepest line on its face and call that the original shape. At Abermagwr in Wales, excavators recorded roofing pieces made from local shale. Some bear lines following their finished edges. Other lines describe shapes the surviving outlines do not follow. Both are worth recording, especially if a display or a replacement template will be based on the collection.
The excavation report offers several explanations for the extra outlines. A worker could have tried a different layout, used the stone as a backing while marking another piece, or reshaped a previously used stone. One crossed line cannot decide between those possibilities. The authors also observed that fine marks survived better on one of the two local mudstones than on the harder material. Counting only visible scratches would give an uneven picture of how often the roofers marked their work.
Keep the cut edge and the incised line separate
On the catalogue sketch, use one line type for the physical perimeter, another for observed marks and a third for any proposed continuation across a broken corner. Keep the original photograph alongside the sketch. In a display label, describe where a mark begins and ends before suggesting its purpose. For a reconstruction, identify which dimensions come from complete edges and which depend on an interpretation. The historic slate archive guide lists other records that can help when documenting a more recent building.
